Main Auction vs Long-Term Decarbonized Power Source Auction — The Critical Differences Battery Operators Must Know
While both fall under the "capacity market" framework, the Main Auction and LDA have fundamentally different design philosophies. We organize the criteria for deciding which to participate in.
In a Nutshell
Main Auction = "A system to receive annual maintenance costs for existing power sources"
→ 1-year contract, single-price, existing and new OK, win rate over 96%
LDA = "A system to receive construction + fixed costs for new sources over 20 years"
→ 20-year contract, multi-price, new only, win rate 20%
The Main Auction is a market where all power sources participate to secure "next year's power supply capacity." The LDA is a market that guarantees "20-year investment recovery" only for new decarbonized power sources. While both fall under the capacity market umbrella, their participation purposes and risk characteristics are entirely different.
7 Differences at a Glance
Comparison Item
Main Auction
LDA
Contract Period
1 year (annual)
20 years in principle
Auction Format
Single-price (last winner's price applies to all)
Multi-price (each bidder's price becomes their contract)
Eligible Sources
All sources, existing and new
New construction, replacement, renovation only
Min. Battery Capacity
1,000kW
30,000kW (from 2nd round)
Revenue from Other Markets
No restrictions (all of it retained)
Obligation to refund ~90% (3 tiers: 95%/90%/85%)
Battery Win Rate
Over 96%
20-24%
Contract Price Level
3,109-14,812 yen/kW (1st-5th rounds)
58,000-68,000 yen/kW/year (decarbonized avg.)
Source: Agency for Natural Resources and Energy "About the Capacity Market" (Feb 5, 2025) / OCCTO contract results
Main Auction Contract Price History — A Roller Coaster
Round
Delivery Year
Avg. Price
Total Value
Notes
1st
FY2024
14,137 yen/kW
—
Nationwide uniform. Near demand curve cap, criticized
2nd
FY2025
3,495 yen/kW
—
Plunged to ~1/4 of previous round
3rd
FY2026
5,226 yen/kW
—
Area-based market segmentation occurred
4th
FY2027
7,847 yen/kW
—
Shifted to upward trend
5th
FY2028
11,134 yen/kW
approx. ¥1.8506 trillion
Record high
Source: OCCTO contract results for each round
In the 5th round, significant area-based disparities emerged. The Hokkaido, Tohoku, and Tokyo areas cleared at the price cap of 14,812 yen/kW, while Kyushu was 13,177 yen, Chubu 10,280 yen, and Hokuriku/Kansai/Chugoku/Shikoku 8,785 yen. The battery installation area directly determines Capacity Market revenue.
Practical Differences for Battery Operators
Batteries Suited for the Main Auction
- Existing batteries (LDA only accepts new construction)
- Small projects under 30MW (below LDA minimum bid capacity)
- Full merchant developers with market trading expertise
- Award rate over 96% with nearly all volume awarded -- can retain all of the revenue from other markets but bears annual price fluctuation risk
Batteries Suited for the LDA
- New large-scale batteries (30MW or more)
- Projects requiring project finance structuring
- For infrastructure funds and institutional investors prioritizing long-term stable income
- Award rate is a highly competitive 20-24%. IRR converges to approx. 3.2% "bond-like returns" from capacity payments alone, but 20-year fixed income makes DSCR structuring easier
Participation Decision Framework
Q1: Existing or new?
→ Existing → Main Auction only (LDA not eligible)
Q2: Is the capacity 30MW or more?
→ Under 30MW → Main Auction only (doesn't meet LDA requirements)
Q3: Is project finance needed?
→ Yes → Prioritize LDA (20-year fixed income is decisive for lending decisions)
Q4: Can you bear market price volatility risk?
→ Yes (+ have market operations capability) → Main Auction + 3-market full merchant
→ Want to limit risk → LDA
Can You Participate in Both?
Sources that win the LDA do not participate in the Main Auction (as they provide supply capacity under the LDA capacity contract). However, if unsuccessful in the LDA, it is possible to participate in the Main Auction again.
Additionally, trading in JEPX and balancing markets by LDA-winning sources is permitted, but the majority (approximately 90%) of that revenue is subject to refund to OCCTO.
Summary — Not "Which is Better" but "Which Fits Your Company"
The Main Auction vs LDA is not a question of "which is more advantageous" — the optimal choice changes based on business phase, scale, and risk tolerance.
However, the common truth is that regardless of which you participate in, "location" is everything. Whether you can secure a suitable site with low grid connection costs is the biggest variable in profitability.
Works on the development, sale and technical due diligence of grid-scale battery storage plants in Japan. This column is written and supervised on the basis of that hands-on transaction and due-diligence practice.
If you are buying, grid-scale BESS projects in Japan that hold a connection study response are for sale on Chikudensho Market, open to view without registration. If you are selling, we either buy the project ourselves or introduce you to a buyer.